Causes and Consequences of
Human-Wildlife Conflict
Spring 2022

TR 11:10 AM - 12:30 PM
GRISE HALL 134

Section 001
CRN: 45572


Douglas Clayton Smith
Professor of Sociology

131 Grise Hall WKU Office Phone:  (270) 745-3131 
Department of Sociology and Criminology Email:  Douglas.Smith@wku.edu
Western Kentucky University Personal Webpage:  people.wku.edu/Douglas.Smith/
1906 College Heights Blvd. #11057  
Bowling Green, KY 42101-1057  
Office Hours: I will be available Mondays and Wednesdays between 9:00--10:00 AM and between 12:30--1:00 PM or by appointment on Zoom.
 

Michael Stokes
Professor of Biology

KTH 3015 WKU Office Phone: (270) 745-6009
Department of Biology Email: Michael.Stokes@wku.edu
Western Kentucky University  
1906 College Heights Blvd. #11080  
Bowling Green, KY 42101-1080  
Office Hours: After class or by appointment
WKU Catalog Description: Global study of human-wildlife conflict and the varying ecological, social, economic, and cultural realities than influence this conflict.

COURSE DESCRIPTION:

Human-wildlife conflict is a persistent social, economic, and ecological problem. As human populations grow and expand into new territory, they compete with wildlife for land and resources. This conflict results in loss or destruction of habitat, poaching of wildlife, social changes in human and wildlife communities, economic losses, and loss of life within human populations. This course examines human-wildlife conflict across the globe and the different ecological and social realities that exist on different continents. The course also examines how human-wildlife conflict at the local level shapes, and is shaped by culture and by transnational, governmental, and non-governmental efforts to curb poaching, preserve valuable habitat, and address issues of extreme poverty in the developing world.

LEARNING OUTCOMES:

This course fulfills the WKU Colonnade Connections Course Requirement - Local to Global Category (3 hours). Upon completion of this course, students will be able to:

  1. Analyze the problem of human-wildlife conflict within a variety of local contexts using sociological and ecological theories and research
  2. Examine the relationship between human-wildlife conflict at a local level and the development of transnational and non-governmental institutions created to address this social and ecological problem
  3. Evaluate the effectiveness and efficacy of specific strategies designed to mitigate human-wildlife conflict, especially in developing countries with high level of extreme poverty
  4. Collect relevant research evidence and argue different perspectives on the inherently divisive issue of conservation vs. utilization of natural resources given the sociocultural realities in a selected case/cases.

REQUIRED MATERIAL:

There is no required text for this course. Articles will be assigned and posted on Blackboard. These articles will be from journals and/or books in the fields of conservation biology and sociology, which may include Conservation Biology, Society and Natural Resources, and Human Dimensions of Wildlife. 

COURSE ORGANIZATION:

This 3-credit hour course will require approximately three hours of direct faculty instruction each week. In addition, you may expect to spend approximately six hours on out-of-class student work for this course each week for approximately 15 weeks. Out-of-class work may include but is not limited to: required reading, library research, written assignments, and studying for and taking exams. 


EVALUATION AND GRADING:

Students will be evaluated based on the following performance indicators:

  1. Midterm examination (20% of the final grade): The midterm exam will be administered after completion of Lessons 1-6. It will require students to apply and synthesize information presented and discussed in Lessons 1-6 in three written essay responses.
  2. Final examination (20% of the final grade): The final exam will be administered after completion of Lessons 7-11. It will require students to apply and synthesize information presented and discussed in Lessons 7-11 and information included in the student group presentations. Similar to the midterm examination, students will be required to respond to three essay questions.
  3. Group Presentation (20% of the final grade): Students will be divided into groups of four or five students, and they will develop and give a 12-15 minute presentation focused on a specific case study or issue related to human-wildlife conflict in the world. Each group will divide into at least two smaller groups and present opposing sides of the issue using existing theories or research presented in the course. The case study selected must demonstrate how human-wildlife conflict at a local level affects actions taken by nation states, non-governmental and transnational organizations at a global level. Students must also address how these global institutions affect, for better or worse, efforts to mitigate human-wildlife conflict for local communities.
  4. Research Paper (20% of the final grade): Each student will submit a final research paper that examines and evaluates the efficacy of a strategy used to mitigate human-wildlife conflict in a local context and to assess this strategy’s potential generalizability for alleviating human-wildlife conflict on a global scale. Students will be required to investigate and research the strategy used and to evaluate and discuss the strategy’s effectiveness using published research. Students may pursue an example that serves as a longitudinal case study (one strategy in one location over time) or one that yields a comparative study (one strategy compared across different geographical areas). The professors are happy to meet with students individually to identify a strategy/topic they might explore for this final paper upon request. The final paper must focus on a case study not presented in class. The final paper will be 5-6 pages (word-processed, double-spaced, 12-point New Times Roman font, 1 inch margins) and include a bibliography in addition to the required 5-6 pages. Students may follow either the MPA or APA citation formats.
  5. In class assignments & activities (20% of the final grade): Each student will complete several in-class assignments and activities designed to require synthesis and application of the material presented in lectures and readings assigned for homework. These in-class activities and assignments will also be used to track attendance and participation.

Students must submit exams, papers, projects, and in-class activities/assignments on the date specified.

All your grades will be posted on the course Blackboard site: https://wku.blackboard.com/

If you are part of a working group, your individual grade will reflect in part your individual contributions to the group project. If one or two students "carry" the group, those students will receive the best grades.

The first step in resolving a complaint about grades is for the student to attempt to resolve the problem directly with the course instructors. See the Student Handbook, available at http://www.wku.edu/handbook/ for additional guidance.  

GRADING SCALE:

90.0 to 100.0

A

80.0 to 89.9

B

70.0 to 79.9

C

60.0 to 69.9

D

Below 60

F

TENTATIVE COURSE SCHEDULE:

This is a general schedule of quiz dates  and readings to be done in preparation for class.

Week 1

Part One: Introduction

Intro to the Course

Defining Human Wildlife Conflict

Redpath, Stephen Mark, Saloni Bhatia. and Juliette Young. 2015. Tilting at Wildlife: Reconsidering Human–wildlife Conflict. Oryx, 49(2):222-225

Treves, Adrian and Francisco J. Santiago-Avila. 2020. "Myths and Assumptions about Human-Wildlife Conflict and Coexistence." Conservation Biology 34(4):811-818.

Week 2 Historical and Evolutionary Perspective on HWC

Hart, Donna and Robert W. Sussman. 2005. Man the Hunted: Primates, Predators, and Human Evolution (excerpt)

Alves, Romulo Romeu Nobrega, Maria Franco Trindade Medeiros, Ulysses Paulino Albuquerque, and Ierece Lucena Rosa. 2013. "From Past to Present: Medicinal Animals in a Historical Perspective." Pp. 10-23 in Animals in Traditional Folk Medicine: Implications for Conservation. New York: Springer.

Evans, E.P. 1906. The Criminal Prosecution and Capital Punishment of Animals. (excerpt)

Ecological Principles of Wildlife Management

Gigliotti, Larry M. Duane L. Shroufe, and Scott Gurtin. 2009. "The Changing Culture of Wildlife Management." Pp. 75-89 in Wildlife and Society: The Science of Human Dimensions. Washington, Island Press.

Conover, Michael R. and Denise O. Conover. 2022. "Philosophy." Pp. 1-28 in Human-Wildlife Interactions: From Conflict to Coexistence, 2nd ed. Boca Raton: CRC Press.

Roach, Mary. 2021. "Okay, Boomer:" in Pp. 171-185 in Fuzz: When Nature Breaks the Law.  New York: W. W. Norton and Company

 

Week 3 Social Science and Human/Wildlife Management

Bell, Michael Mayerfield. 2009. "Sustainability, Environmental Justice and the Rights of Nature." Pp. 7-29 in An Invitation to Environmental Sociology, 3rd ed. Los Angeles: Pine Forge Press.

Bennett, Nathan J. et al. 2017. "Conservation Social Science: Understanding and Integrating Human Dimensions to Improve Conservation. Biological Conservation 205: 93-108.

Kellert, Stephen Robert. 1993. "Attitudes, Knowledge, and Behavior toward Wildlife among the Industrial Superpowers: United States, Japan, and Germany." Journal of Social Issues 49(1):53-69.

Part Two: Wildlife and Society

Wildlife in World Culture

Manfredo, Michael J. and Ashley A. Dayer. 2004. "Concepts for Exploring the Social Aspects of Human-Wildlife Conflict in a Global Context." Human Dimensions of Wildlife 9:317-328.

Chaney, Robert. 2020. "Ursus horribilis Facebookii." pp. 22-44 in The Grizzly in the Driveway: The Return of Bears to a Crowded American West. Seattle: University of Washington Press.

Week 4 Geography -- urban/rural, metro/nonmetro

Soulsbury, C.D. and White, P.C., 2015. Human–wildlife interactions in urban areas: a review of conflicts, benefits and opportunities. Wildlife research, 42(7), pp.541-553.

Margulies, J.D. and Karanth, K.K., 2018. The production of human-wildlife conflict: A political animal geography of encounter. Geoforum, 95, pp.153-164.

Social and Demographic Trends -- The Pressures of Growth and Urbanization

Scanes, C.G., 2018. Human activity and habitat loss: destruction, fragmentation, and degradation. In Animals and human society (pp. 451-482). Academic Press.

Ogega, O.M., Wanjohi, H.N. and Mbugua, J., 2019. "Exploring the Future of Nairobi National Park in a Changing Climate and Urban Growth. In The Geography of Climate Change Adaptation in Urban Africa (pp. 249-272). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.

Mustățea, M. and Pătru-Stupariu, I., 2021. Using Landscape Change Analysis and Stakeholder Perspective to Identify Driving Forces of Human–Wildlife Interactions. Land, 10(2), p.146.

Week 5 Climate Change

Munguia-Carrara, Mariana. 2020. "From Human-Wildlife Conflicts to Human-Wildlife Coexistence in Anthropocene Landscapes. Agricultural Research and Technology: Open Access. 24(4): 140-144.

Abrahms, Briana. 2021. "Human-wildlife Conflict under Climate Change." Science 373(6554):484-485.

Part Three: Basic Needs

Food and Water -- subsistence farming and provisioning from nature

Nyamwamu, Ronald Orare. 2016. "Implications of Human-Wildlife Conflict on Food Security among Smallholder Agro-Pastoralists: A Case of Smallholder Maize (Zea mays) Farmers in Laikipia County, Kenya." World Journal of Agricultural Research 4(2):43-48.

Ogra, M. V. (2008). Human–wildlife conflict and gender in protected area borderlands: a case study of costs, perceptions, and vulnerabilities from Uttarakhand (Uttaranchal), India. Geoforum, 39(3), 1408-1422.

Week 6 Stratification, Inequality, and Poverty

Case study: Poaching

Knapp, E. J., Peace, N., & Bechtel, L. (2017). Poachers and poverty: assessing objective and subjective measures of poverty among illegal hunters outside Ruaha National Park, Tanzania. Conservation and Society, 15(1), 24-32.

Moreto, W.D., 2019. Provoked poachers? Applying a situational precipitator framework to examine the nexus between human-wildlife conflict, retaliatory killings, and poaching. Criminal Justice Studies, 32(2), pp.63-80.

Anagnostou, Michelle, William D. Moreto, Charlie J. Gardner, and Brent Doberstein. 2021. "Poverty, Pandemics, and Wildlife Crime." Conservation and Society 19(4):294-306. (12p)

Week 7 Land Tenure and Property Rights

Mc Guinness, S. K. (2016). Perceptions of crop raiding: effects of land tenure and agro‐industry on human–wildlife conflict. Animal Conservation, 19(6), 578-587.

Sadie, Y. (2019). Human-wildlife conflict and wildlife conservation: Attitudes of the Ovahimbas in Namibia. Conflict Trends, 2019(3), 38-46.

MIDTERM

Week 8 Case study: Habitat loss, agriculture and elephant populations (Mike)  

Energy production and consumption

Patricelli, G.L., Blickley, J.L. and Hooper, S.L., 2013. Recommended management strategies to limit anthropogenic noise impacts on greater sage-grouse in Wyoming. Human-Wildlife Interactions, 7(2), pp.230-249.

Loss, S.R., 2016. Avian interactions with energy infrastructure in the context of other anthropogenic threats. The Condor: Ornithological Applications, 118(2), pp.424-432.

Week 9 SPRING BREAK
Week 10

Part Four: Trade in Wildlife

Legal and Illegal Trade in Animal Parts

Alves, Romulo Romeu Nobrega  and Ierece Lucena Rosa. 2013. "Introduction: Toward a Plural Approach to the Study of Medicinal Animals." Pp. 1-9 in Animals in Traditional Folk Medicine: Implications for Conservation. New York: Springer.

Alves, Romulo Romeu Nobrega, Ierece Lucena Rosa, Ulysses Paulino Albuquerque, and Anthony B. Cunningham. 2013. "Medicine from the Wild: An Overview of the Use and Trade of Animal Products in Traditional Medicines." Pp. 25-42 in Animals in Traditional Folk Medicine: Implications for Conservation. New York: Springer.

Arias, M., Hinsley, A., Nogales‐Ascarrunz, P., Carvajal‐Bacarreza, P. J., Negroes, N., Glikman, J. A., & Milner‐Gulland, E. J. (2021). Complex interactions between commercial and noncommercial drivers of illegal trade for a threatened felid. Animal Conservation.

Efforts to Quell the Illegal Trade in Animals and Animal Parts

Goyes DR and Sollund R (2016) Contesting and contextualising CITES: Wildlife trafficking in Colombia and Brazil. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy 5(4): 87-102. DOI: 10.5204/ijcjsd.v5i4.331.

Week 11 Case study: rhino poaching, organized crime and international trafficking (Mike & Doug)  
Week 12  
Week 13 Presentations
Week 14 Presentations
Week 15

Part Five: The Future: Conflict or Coexistence?

Technology

The Future of Human-Wildlife Conflict

DeCaro, Daniel and Michael K. Stokes. 2013. "Public Participation and Institutional Fit: A Social-Psychological Perspective." Ecology and Society 38(4):40

Lamarque, F., Anderson, J., Fergusson, R., Lagrange, M., Osei-Owusu, Y., & Bakker, L. (2009). Human-wildlife conflict in Africa: causes, consequences and management strategies (No. 157). Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO).

Week 16 Finals Week (May 2 -- May 5)

COURSE NORMS:

RESOURCE INFORMATION:

The Writing Center on the Bowling Green campus will have writing tutors available to offer advice to current WKU students on any stage of their writing projects. In-person tutoring is available in Cherry Hall 123 from 9-4 Monday through Friday and in the Cravens Commons (at the horseshoe-shaped reference desk) from 5-9 on Sunday through Thursday evenings. Students may also request feedback on their writing via email or arrange a real-time Zoom conference to discuss a paper. See instructions and how-to videos on the website (www.wku.edu/writingcenter) for making appointments. Walk-in feedback is available unless we are booked up. Students may also get short writing questions answered via email; just put "Quick question" in the subject line to (writingcenter@wku.edu).  

The WKU Glasgow START Center/Writing Center will be offering writing tutoring sessions as well as in person. More information on how to make appointments and what to expect from your appointment will continue to be posted at https://www.wku.edu/startcenter/

TLC (located in Downing Student Union 2141) offers an ideal environment to foster student success. Students can take advantage of a vast array of services to supplement course specific content distributed within the classroom. For example, students may utilize the large, quiet study space or their 12 machine computer lab to complete assignments. TLC also provides face-to-face tutoring in over 200 WKU courses by our certified tutors. TLC offers online tutoring as well. In addition to specific courses, TLC offers tutoring in many academic skill areas including time management, note taking strategies, and reading comprehension. 

In compliance with University policy, students with disabilities who require academic and/or auxiliary accommodations for this course must contact the Student Accessibility Resource Center located in Downing Student Union, Room 1074.  The SARC can be reached by phone number at 270-745-5004 [270-745-3030 TTY] or via email at sarc.connect@wku.edu. Please do not request accommodations directly from the professor or instructor without a faculty notification letter (FNL) from The Student Accessibility Resource Center.

SYLLABUS CHANGE POLICY:

The syllabus for any class is a road map. The readings in the course calendar are places we are scheduled to visit.  Anyone who has taken a preplanned road trip or vacation knows that the trip is not fun unless you stop at the interesting roadside attractions even though they might divert from your original route or time table.  It's the process of getting there that is fun and relaxing and intriguing.  In that light, I reserve the right to alter the standards and requirements set forth in this syllabus at any time. Notice of such changes will be by announcement on Blackboard and/or by email notice.

ADD/DROP DATES:

Last day to add a full semester class: January 25

Last day to drop a full semester class without receiving a grade: January 25

Last day to receive 25% refund for the Spring semester: February 7

The 60% point of the Spring semester: March 27

Last day to drop a class with a W: April 5

Last day to remove an incomplete from Fall or Winter terms: April 15

Roster freeze date (No late adds or withdrawals for extenuating circumstances will be processed after this date): April 28

HONOR CODE: 

Students are expected to adhere to the Student Code of Conduct. We will not tolerate any form of academic dishonesty, including cheating and plagiarism (especially on your exams and papers). Persons violating the Student Code of Conduct (in particular but not limited to the section on academic conduct) in any assignment or exam in this class will receive an "F" for the course.  In particular, no form of academic misconduct will be tolerated (see https://www.wku.edu/studentconduct/process-for-academic-dishonesty.php.) Know your Regulations!