Note: "Push models" suggest that some factor(s) pushed
societies
to become more complex; "pull models" suggest that some factor(s)
permitted
societies to become more complex.
Environmental / Ecological Explanations
something about the environment leads to complexity
may be a harsh environment, which challenges humans to adapt more complexity (push model)
may be a rich environment, which allows for food surpluses and social classes (pull model)
may be a diverse environment, which requires more interaction to get
scattered resources (push model)
Population Increase Explanations
population growth may lead to more complicated social relationships that require an institutionalized means of guiding behavior (push model)
or, population increase may give incentive to develop more
technologies
and social organizations to deal with more people (pull model)
Technological Explanations
technology includes tools (ceramics, metallurgy, plows, bow and arrow, etc.) or writing
either inventions led to more efficient use of the environment and food surpluses, which allowed development of complexity (pull model)
or, the need to control surpluses and other materials led to development of technological methods of controlling trade, distribution and craft specialization (push model)
Irrigation Explanations (Julian Steward, Karl Wittfogel)
the need to increase food supplies led to the development of irrigation systems
irrigation systems required greater complexity to organize labor, to feed workers, to plan and build the canal system, to maintain canals, and to distribute water (push model)
Exchange Explanations
scattered resources in an area may led to a class of traders, demand for goods leads to craft specialists
food surpluses are required to support traders and craft persons, a means of transporting goods is required, a method of standardizing goods and services is needed, and an institutionalized means of controlling resource access and redistribution (pull model)
Environmental
Circumscription / Warfare
(Robert Carniero)
states arose in areas where the expansion of a growing population was restricted such that conflicts between groups over resources developed
conflict s among groups in restricted regions led to warfare and control of the losing group by the winning group
when this power becomes greater and is institutionalized,
state-level
societies result (pull model)
Religion Explanations
early religious figures in a society functioned to insure fertility of the crops and herd and to control agricultural cycles like planting and harvesting, both through observation of the stars and ritual sacrifices
these roles led to control of food surpluses and redistribution of goods by the religious leaders, which elevated their status and power in society
as power was gained and institutionalized and expanded beyond
subsistence
pursuits, complex society (often a theocracy) was formed (pull
model)
Class Conflict
disputes between social groups led to the need to develop an institutionalized means of resolving disputes
this led to many characteristics associated with states like strong, centralized governments, force as a means of social control and codified law
complex society developed as a problem solver; it developed to
maintain
order (pull model)
REFER TO THE FAGAN TEXT FOR MORE DETAILS