Anth 450 Modern Human Biological Variation
Dr. Darlene Applegate
Fall 2007
Chapter Summaries: Ideas
Listed below are suggestions of main ideas to consider when reading
Gould's The Mismeasure of Man
and composing a chapter summary.
INTRODUCTION TO THE REVISED AND
EXPANDED EDITION and
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
- three-part framework of the book
- goal(s) of writing the book and revising the book
- issue of scientific objectivity
- concept of biological determinism
- two fallacies of biological determinism
- two weaknesses of biological determinism as it relates to
intelligence
- two methods traditionally used to measure intelligence
- his approach to examining biological determinism and intelligence
research
CHAPTER 2 AMERICAN POLYGENY AND
CRANIOMETRY BEFORE DARWIN
- polygenism vs. monogenism
- Agassiz: views on polygenism
- Morton: craniometric methods, results, four errors
- social implications / relationship to slavery
CHAPTER 3 MEASURING HEADS
- craniology and quantification
- Galton’s
quantification and views on biological determinism of traits
- Bean’s studies of
the corpus callosum
- Gould's four objections/contentions
- Broca: strengths and weaknesses of research, craniological
approaches, four rankings (French vs. German, criminals, diachronic
changes, male vs. female)
CHAPTER 4 MEASURING BODIES
This chapter considers two
arguments about evolution.
- Haeckel and the definition of recapitulation
- relationship to ranking human races
- Cope's methods and rankings
- the replacement of recapitulation with neoteny and Bolk's
rankings
- Lombroso’s criminal anthropology
- influence of criminal anthropology
- resurgence of criminal anthropology in 1960s as innate
criminology
CHAPTER 5 THE HEREDITARIAN THEORY OF IQ
This is a
very long chapter. Regarding the four major people discussed in this
chapter, you need to have something about each of these
individuals, but you won't be able to cover all of the information in
one page. So, touch on a few
of the topics listed
for each below.
- Binet and the IQ scale: reason for developing IQ test, concerns
about how test might be misused, three cardinal principles
- fallacies of reification and hereditarianism (inevitability) in
relation to IQ testing
- Goddard’s hereditarian view of intelligence: unilineal scale of
intelligence and other allegedly related behaviors, concerns with
morons, inheritance of intelligence, social implications and eugenics,
changes in opinion
- Terman’s hereditarian view of intelligence: changes to Binet’s
test, social implications and eugenics, Cox’s work [not that critical],
relative contribution of nature vs. nurture in polymorphic variation in
intelligence, changes in opinion
- Yerkes’ hereditarian view of intelligence: military intelligence
testing, social implications, problems with the tests in terms of
construction and administration
CHAPTER 6 THE REAL ERROR OF CYRIL BURT
Spend more
time discussing Burt and Spearman than Thurstone and Jensen.
- Burt: correlation and causation, factor analysis (don’t agonize
over the details), reification of g (general intelligence) and factors
of g, hereditarian view of intelligence, political uses of ideas,
instances of fraud
- Spearman: statistics, reification, g (general intelligence) and s
(specific loci) factors of intelligence, hereditarian view of
intelligence, how his research was used/misused
- Thurstone: vectors of the mind, Spearman’s and Burt’s reactions
to Thurstone, PMA's
- Jensen: use of g to rank all life forms, reification of g,
hereditarian view of intelligence
CHAPTER 7 A POSITIVE CONCLUSION and EPILOGUE
- debunking: definition, benefits
- sociobiology: definition, why it is problematic, examples
- neoteny: definition, relationship to evolution
THE BELL CURVE
- Herrnstein and Murray: two arguments (social Darwinism and
hereditarian view of intelligence), focus on populations rather than
individuals, major problems with argument
- ghosts of bell curves past: Gobineau, four premises, misuse of
Binet
THREE CENTURIES’ PERSPECTIVES ON RACE
AND RACISM
- Browne and debunking: category mistakes, surrogacy
- African-Americans with lower innate intelligence: definitional
problems
- racial geometry and racial classification: Blumenbach, Linnaeus
- Darwin: views on human nature
Return to the Modern Human
Biological
Variation Home Page
Visit the Western Kentucky University
Home
Page, Western Online
Page composed by Darlene Applegate, darlene.applegate@wku.edu
Last updated on August 29, 2007
All contents copyright (c) 2007. Western Kentucky
University.